Friends can be huge assets in the world of professional wrestling. If you’re friends with the wrestlers that you’re working with, that can create a positive work environment where everyone is willing to co-operate. With that much trust in one another, it allows a lot more freedom when working together especially with someone that you get along with. There’s no other group that demonstrates this than the group known as the Kliq.
Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon gave us a legendary ladder match at WrestleMania X. Kevin Nash and Scott Hall gave us the Outsiders. Triple H and Shawn Michaels gave us fond memories as D-Generation X and as bitter enemies. These folks have gotten along very well and the work they’ve done together demonstrated this… most of the time.
Sometimes it just doesn’t… kliq. We’ll be looking at once of those examples, when former Kliq buddies feuded in a storyline best forgotten. We’ll see if we can turn the 2003 feud between The Game and Big Daddy Cool into something that’s too sweet…
…here’s How I Would Book… Triple H vs. Kevin Nash in 2003.
Now that I have gotten my obligatory kliq/click pun out of the way, it’s time to tackle the first feud in WWE between Triple H and Kevin Nash. They had a rivalry in 2003 that led to a Hell in a Cell match and they had another rivalry in 2011 that led to a sledgehammer ladder match… yes, that was a thing.
For this “How I Would Book…”, we’ll only focus on their 2003 rivalry. I may consider doing the 2011 program too but, if we’re being honest, the whole storyline between Triple H, Kevin Nash and CM Punk was just a massive mess to begin with that you’d need to do a lot with in order to untangle. It probably would be better off if we did a “Summer of Punk” redo and even something like that would be a tall order with a lot of work involved.
However, the 2003 program between Nash and Triple H was interesting given that the timing couldn’t have lined up any better. Nash returned after Triple H started a huge feud with Shawn Michaels and had just retained the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania XIX. It seemed like a great time to slide Nash into the world title picture against one of his real-life best friends.
Unfortunately, what had the potential of a great storyline involving three best friends turned into just another predictable world title program for 2003 Triple H. It really was ALL ABOUT THE GAME in 2003.
Let’s break down what happened and see how we could re-write the storyline better than WWE did…
Kevin Nash had been out of action since around June/July 2002 when he went down with an injury. At the time, Nash was a part of the New World Order stable along with Shawn and was trying to recruit Triple H to join the group (or at least it was teased, I think). However, Nash’s injury and a whole bunch of different factors led to the New World Order stable being scrapped all together. In fact, we actually did do a “How I Would Book…” for the 2002 nWo storyline many years ago. The links to that series are available at the bottom of this post.
By the time Nash returned on the night after WrestleMania XIX, things were hugely different. Since Nash had been away, Triple H and Shawn Michaels began a heated feud with each other which led Nash to breaking up a scuffle between the pair on an episode of RAW. Nash did not want to attack either of his friends but saved Shawn from a beat-down from Triple H’s posse at the time.
Nash try to get the friends to reconcile but neither Triple H nor Shawn were having it. They confirmed that their rivalry would never be over and Triple H made it clear that Nash had to pick a side. Triple H said Nash would need to take orders from Triple H but at least he was honest about it. Triple H brought up Shawn’s history of backstabbing people and told Nash that Shawn would turn his back on him too.
Nash still refused to take sides in the feud which led Triple H making the decision for him. Triple H low-blowed Kevin Nash about a week or two later, which led to Nash and Triple H becoming enemies. This led to a six man tag team match at Backlash with Triple H, Ric Flair and Chris Jericho facing Booker T, Nash and Shawn*, which Triple H’s team won as he pinned Nash.
NOTE: Ironically, Booker, Shawn and Nash were all members of the nWo together at one point during the 2002 WWE run!
The feud had problems in the next few months, with Nash himself not particularly being beloved as a babyface. For example, Nash was getting booed on an episode of RAW in Canada that led to a huge brawl between Nash and Triple H in the arena. The segment was actually one of the highlights of the feud with the brawl actually looking really good.
Nash ended up becoming somewhat of a side-character in the build up to their Bad Blood match as well, with the emphasis being put on the special referee Mick Foley.
Nash challenged for the World Heavyweight title three times on pay-per-view. Kevin Nash challenged Triple H for the title at Judgement Day, which led to a disqualification and Kevin Nash power=bombing Triple H through the announce table. They had another match at the Insurrextion UK pay-per-view which Triple H won. They had a final match at Bad Blood inside the Hell in a Cell, where Triple H beat Nash with Mick Foley as the special guest referee.
Nash was still in the company for a few months afterwards, feuding with Chris Jericho, being shaved bald and then losing in the Elimination Chamber match at SummerSlam 2003.
As I mentioned before, this storyline had great potential with a simple set-up. A best friend comes back after a long time away to see that everything has changed and his friends are fighting each other. Heck, Triple H turned on Shawn about a month or so after Nash’s injury so you can already tell the storyline of how the whole thing went to hell without Nash being there. Now he’s back and something’s got to give.
However, WWE really was at fault with this storyline for a few reasons:
1. They had Triple H turn on Kevin Nash SO DAMN FAST. It was about two weeks into the storyline when Triple H “made the decision” for Nash by attacking him, which depleted weeks’ worth of storyline potential where you can tease Nash either siding with Shawn or siding with Triple H. What was the point in throwing that all away in the space of a few weeks? You had a six man tag team match already booked for Backlash where Nash was teaming with Shawn against Triple H. You could have promoted the match by teasing whether Nash would go with Shawn or Triple H. I mean… IT WAS RIGHT THERE.
2. Triple H came off as a massive idiot for attacking Nash BEFORE Backlash. Nash was already hesitant to wrestle Triple H before Backlash, which Triple H could use to his advantage. Either he could lead Nash into a false sense of security and then turn on him or he could try to cause friction within Nash’s team by having him turn on Shawn. Triple H betrayed one of his best friends RIGHT BEFORE a big match against him, which would no doubt piss off the seven-foot giant.
3. Nash lost almost every match he had on pay-per-view. Sure, he “defeated” Triple H at Judgement Day but it was via disqualification. He still never won the championship and he even took the pin in a six man tag team match against Backlash. That type of booking was ludicrous, given that Nash was set to start a world title program with Triple H for the next pay-per-view. Why didn’t Nash’s team just win the six man tag match and pin either Ric Flair or Chris Jericho?
4. Nash was just not particularly over as a babyface at this time. One factor was his lack of success in big matches, which I went over in point 3. However, there wasn’t much reason for the fans to get behind Nash after Backlash. Other than him being a giant that could destroy Triple H, there wasn’t much reason to get invested in his story after Triple H turned on him. He became just another challenger to Triple H and the babyface run was such a disaster, that Mick Foley had to be brought in as the special referee for the Hell in a Cell match. Nash became the third wheel in a one-on-one Hell in a Cell match!
5. After the Hell in a Cell match, there was little else for Nash to do in WWE. Goldberg was put in the World title picture and was basically the babyface monster that RAW needed, while Nash was reduced to getting his head shaved by Jericho. His momentum died out very quickly.
I feel I could go on and on but the major crooks was the lack of development in the Nash/Triple H/Shawn love triangle of sorts! I, at least, want to dabble in this just a little bit as part of this “How I Would Book…” post. So without further ado, let’s get into it…
Nash’s return stays in tact. They did it absolutely fine and there was immediate buzz in Nash as well as investment into the story, with him literally standing in the middle of the Shawn Michaels/Triple H rivalry. Perfect foundation for a storyline.
We’re also going to keep in the segment from the next week’s RAW, where Triple H spelled things out for Nash. Triple H tells Nash to make a choice. Does he stand behind Triple H and work FOR him or does he work WITH a Shawn Michaels who could possibly betray him?
The six man tag team match for Backlash still happens and still promoted but we do not have Triple H attacking Nash before the match. That was just too fast and we need to drag this out a little bit more. The tension between Nash, Booker T and Shawn is a pivotal part of the build to the match, with Triple H stirring the pot. This leads to the six man tag match. The match spills out omto a big brawl, where Shawn inadvertently Super Kicks Nash over the top rope. If you’ll recall, Shawn eliminated Big Daddy Cool Diesel from the 1996 Royal Rumble match in the exact same way. It’s inadvertent déjà vu for Nash, who gets mad. He gets so mad that he powerbombs Shawn in retaliation and walks out in frustration. Triple H pins Shawn and has gained from the situation.
We build towards Judgement Day, where Nash is booked to face Shawn Micheals in a number one contendership match for the World Heavyweight Championship. Nash and Shawn squabble heading into the pay-per-view, with Shawn pleading that the super kick was just an accident. After weeks of Nash blowing him off, Shawn has enough and super kicks Nash intentionally on the RAW before Judgement Day. They have the match, which results in Ric Flair running down and low-blowing Shawn Michaels. Nash takes advantage, without knowing Ric helped him, and hits Shawn with the Jackknife Powerbomb to win the match. This finish sets up Nash vs. Triple H for the World title and Shawn Michaels vs. Ric Flair… both matches that happened in real life at the Bad Blood 2003 pay-per-view.
While Nash is pleased to be number one contender, he gets mad at Triple H for Ric getting involved. Nash mentions that the issues between Shawn and Nash were between them and not Triple H at this point. Nash said that he wanted to settle it with Shawn in the ring and wants Triple H to settle things with Shawn too. Triple H insists that Ric Flair did not do it with his knowledge and wants to “deal” with Ric for getting involved. He won’t settle things with Shawn but he’ll wrestle Ric Flair for Nash. This leads to the famous Triple H vs. Ric Flair match on RAW, where Ric challenged Triple H for the title in North Carolina. It was a really cool match and I just wanted to keep it in as part of this storyline.
They do a contract signing with Nash and Triple H and Triple H promises that the world title match at Bad Blood will be a pure match. No one will get involved and it will just be a match to see who is the better man. The match is made and Nash takes most of the match, beating up Triple H and dominating. The referee gets knocked down and Triple H goes to get a sledgehammer. However, he promised Nash that the match would be pure. He drops the hammer in the ring but Nash gets back into the match. He goes for the Jackknife Powerbomb but Triple H “accidentally” low blows Nash. Triple H acts shocked and stumbles back into the sledgehammer. Triple H stops, smiles, picks up the hammer and smashes Nash in the head with it. Triple H pins Nash and retains the World Heavyweight Championship.
NOTE: In case anyone is wondering, I didn’t think to book something for Insurrextion. The Insurrextion pay-per-view honestly seemed like a glorified house show and I didn’t feel like putting a match together as part of the storyline. The match between Nash and HHH didn’t really add a lot to the story in real life anyway and I don’t think it’d add a lot to the story here. If you want, just put a tag team match here or something.
Nash is understandably extremely mad as Triple H betrayed Nash’s trust. Triple H promised a pure match but took the low road to win the match. Triple H told Nash that he’d shoot with him straight in their first promo together and then lied straight to his face as part of the Bad Blood build-up. Nash seriously wants revenge. Nash spends the next few months running through Triple H and his friends. Nash beats Ric Flair, Nash beats Randy Orton and this leads to a tag team match on RAW with Kevin Nash and Shawn Michaels against Triple H and Ric Flair. If Nash and Shawn win, Nash and Shawn both get world title shots at SummerSlam 2003. It’d be a triple threat match.
Nash and Shawn are still on uneasy terms after their Judgement Day match but they work together fine as a unit in the RAW match and Nash pins Triple H at last. Therefore, it’s Triple H defending the World title against Shawn Michaels and Kevin Nash. Triple H retains the title against all odds at SummerSlam by hitting the Pedigree on Kevin Nash and retaining the world title.
That wraps up this storyline. It feels weird to omit the Hell in a Cell match from this storyline and end it in a triple threat. However, Shawn should be very prominent in this storyline between best friends given that he’s also a main reason for the conflict. All three former best friends settling it in a triple threat match seems like a fitting way to close the book on the Kevin Nash storyline. Heck, if Nash gets pinned, then it protects Shawn for future matches with Triple H.
That sums up this “How I Would Book…”. I’d like to think by stretching out the Triple H/Nash tension, it’d make for far more compelling story. I considered doing a storyline where Nash joins Evolution somehow but then turns on Triple H, heading into a Hell in a Cell match. However, I wanted Nash to stand out as a character and I think him playing a tweener role adds a great dynamic to the Shawn/Triple H rivalry as well. It really is the Good, the Bad and the Ugly…
Thank you for reading this post and please let me know how you would have tackled this story yourself. Until then, no matter what happens…. STICK THE WINNER FOR ME.
How I Would Book series
#1 – How I Would Book… Rey Mysterio vs AJ Styles
#2 – How I Would Book… Batista vs Brock Lesnar (Part One and Part Two)
#3 – How I Would Book… Wrestlemania 29 (Part One, Part Two, Part Threeand Part Four)
#4 – How I Would Book… Eddie Guerrero’s Road To Wrestlemania 22 (Part Oneand Part Two)
#5 – How I Would Book… The nWo 19th Anniversary Special (Part One, Part Two, Part Three, Part Four, Part Five and Final Part)
#6 – How I Would Book… Roman Reigns vs Undertaker
#7 – How I Would Book… The End Of The Streak (Part One, Part Two (John Cena), Part Three (CM Punk), Part Four (Randy Orton), Part Five (Bray Wyatt), Final Part)
#8 – How I Would Book… Roman Reigns vs The Rock
#9 – How I Would Book… Kurt Angle’s Return To WWE
#10 – How I Would Book… John Cena vs The Rock III
#11 – How I Would Book… Kevin Owens as Intercontinental Champion
#12 – How I Would Book… Christian’s World Title Run In 2011
#13 – How I Would Book… Roman Reigns vs John Cena
#14 – How I Would Book… Dean Ambrose Winning The WWE Championship
#15 – How I Would Book… Batista vs Brock Lesnar vs Undertaker
#16 – How I Would Book… Roman Reigns vs Undertaker (Wrestlemania 32)
#17 – How I Would Book… AJ Styles’ Road to WrestleMania 32
#18 – How I Would Book… CM Punk As Nexus Leader (Part One and Part Two)
#19 – How I Would Book… WrestleMania 32
#20 – How I Would Book… Who Ran Over Stone Cold?
#21 – How I Would Book… Rusev in WWE (Part One, Part Two and Part Three)
#22 – How I Would Book… Wade Barrett in WWE (Part One, Part Two, Part Three, Part Four and Part Five)
#23 – How I Would Book… The 2018 Bayley vs. Sasha Banks Feud
#24 – How I Would Book… Samoa Joe in WWE (Part One, Part Two, Part Three and Part Four)
#25 – How I Would Book… Scott Steiner in WWE